The BOTY award goes to the Barbershopper that has shown outstanding dedication to the chorus that goes above and beyond.
Every year the BOTY Alumni select a new recipient of the BOTY award for that year.
| Dave Bechard | 2024 |
| Harvy Weiss | 2023 |
| Andy Richards | 2022 |
| Dave Casperson | 2021 |
| Steve Grady | 2020 |
| Dan Williams | 2019 |
| Blake Wanger | 2018 |
| Dan True | 2017 |
| Bill Ward | 2016 |
| Rich Ongna | 2015 |
| Rod Vink | 2014 |
| John Carlotto | 2013 |
| Mark Ortenburger | 2012 |
| Dick Riemenschneider | 2011 |
| David Speidel | 2010 |
| Gary Jacobson | 2009 |
| Peter Jarnberg | 2008 |
| Paul Wigley | 2007 |
| Dan Cole | 2006 |
| Mark Sathe | 2005 |
| Joe Houser | 2004 |
| Dan Smith | 2003 |
| Dave Bayer | 2002 |
| Guy St.Martin | 2001 |
| Wes Hatlestad | 2000 |
| Jim Windey | 1999 |
| Bill Hamre | 1998 |
| Pete Villwock | 1997 |
| Carl Pinard | 1996 |
| Chuck Dostal | 1995 |
| Mark Conlon | 1994 |
| Doug Miller | 1993 |
| Bob Griffith | 1992 |
| David George | 1991 |
| Brooks Bergersen | 1990 |
| Merill Miller | 1989 |
| Mike Stump | 1988 |
| Bill Shaw Jr. | 1987 |
| Ron Setzler | 1986 |
| Rod Johnson | 1985 |
| Norm DeCarlo | 1984 |
| Loren Berthilson | 1983 |
| Dan Slatery | 1982 |
| Hardin Olson | 1981 |
| Marv Spears | 1980 |
| Orv Haugan | 1979 |
| Jim Richards | 1978 |
| Will Sheldon | 1977 |
| Bernard Lamotte | 1976 |
| John Hanson | 1975 |
| Bob Dykstra | 1974 |
| Dick Plaisted | 1973 |
| Bob Spong | 1972 |
| Herb Friesen | 1971 |
| Rich Williams | 1970 |
| Harold Ulring | 1969 |
| Art Erlandson | 1968 |
